Burlington, WI roots. Nationwide reach.
Mangold Insurance is a fourth-generation independent agency founded in Burlington, Wisconsin in 1933. We write insurance anywhere in the United States — and we specialize in the small towns and rural communities that national carriers overlook and captive agents underserve.
We write anywhere in the U.S. — we take the time to thoroughly evaluate your needs
No obligation. We shop 100+ carriers and call with real options.
We write anywhere in the U.S. — we take the time to get it right.
Our Burlington office is home base — but through our Robertson Ryan affiliation and 100+ carrier relationships, we can write home, auto, farm, business, and life insurance across the United States. We have deep local expertise in Wisconsin, Illinois, and eastern Iowa. If you're somewhere else, we can still help.
We got our start in Burlington, Wisconsin — a small town, just like the communities we serve. We know what it's like when the nearest independent agent is 30 miles away, or when a national carrier's algorithm can't tell a hobby farm from an industrial operation. We built this agency for places like ours.
If your town doesn't have a local independent agent — or the only options are captive agents selling one company's products — that's exactly who we built this agency for. Your zip code doesn't determine the quality of coverage you deserve.
You talk to a person. They know your county. They understand that your "farm" is 400 acres of corn, not a hobby garden. That context matters when we build your policy.
We review what you actually need and find the gaps the company won't tell you about. We've found them on our own policies.
You decide how we work together. Take care of quotes, policy reviews, and claims guidance by phone, email, or video — without ever driving to Burlington — or sit down with us in person if you prefer. Whatever's easiest for you, wherever you are in the country.
If your broker auto-renews your policy without a conversation, sends a junior rep, or puts you on hold at claim time — you have a vendor, not a partner.
We go further than just placing coverage. We analyze safety programs, review contracts, model deductible structures, and build a custom annual renewal marketing strategy — all focused on controlling your total cost of risk.
"Platinum Terrain has been doing business with Mangold Insurance for many years. Sue Tuma goes above and beyond for all of our service needs and always tries to save us money when possible. I would highly recommend the Mangold team to others!"
— Jennessa Harris · Platinum Terrain · Google Review
Home, farm, contractors, manufacturers, lake homes, business, and life — one independent agency, 100+ carriers, anywhere you need us.
Homeowners, renters, auto, watercraft, and umbrella — we shop 100+ carriers to find the right combination for your household, anywhere in the U.S.
Learn more →Term life, whole life, and disability coverage for individuals, families, and business owners. We find the right fit for your stage of life.
Learn more →Northwoods Wisconsin specialists — dock coverage, watercraft, snowmobiles, ATVs, and short-term rental. Standard policies miss all of this.
Learn more →Proper farm policies for working farms and hobby operations. Structures, equipment, livestock, and farm liability — not homeowners add-ons.
Learn more →General liability, commercial property, workers' comp, BOP, and umbrella — core coverage for businesses of all sizes across every industry.
Learn more →General liability, workers' comp, commercial auto, and tools & equipment for contractors working in Wisconsin, Illinois, and beyond.
Learn more →Product liability, commercial property, equipment breakdown, workers' comp, and commercial umbrella for manufacturers across the region.
Learn more →Dealers, repair shops, body shops, and service garages — coverage for inventory, tools, lifts, and garagekeepers liability.
Learn more →Apartment buildings, condos, and mixed-use properties — building coverage, liability, and loss-of-rents protection.
Learn more →Owner-operators, small fleets, and freight brokers — primary liability, cargo, physical damage, and non-trucking coverage.
Learn more →We write insurance anywhere — but these are the areas we know best.
Not all insurance is the same. Some of it comes with a catchy jingle and a 47-minute hold time. Here's the other kind.
A captive agent works for one company. We work for you, finding the best coverage across 100+ carriers. Our loyalty is to your policy, not a single carrier's quota.
When we shop the market, carriers compete for your business. That's how our clients regularly save hundreds at renewal without giving up coverage. One phone call, 100+ carriers.
When something goes wrong, we help you navigate the claim — not just hand you a 1-800 number. We've been in this community for 90+ years. Our reputation depends on your outcome.
We know what a Jefferson County grain farm needs. We know Northwoods cabin risks. We know McHenry County contractor requirements. That context builds better policies.
James Mangold Sr. opened this agency in 1933 during the Great Depression — when finding reliable insurance was hardest for the families and farmers who needed it most. His belief was simple: small communities deserve the same protection as big cities. That philosophy still drives every policy we write — for clients across the country.
We're now in our fourth generation of Mangold family ownership. 19 agents and staff. Clients in 10 states. In 2019 we partnered with Robertson Ryan & Associates — a Top 100 U.S. independent agency — expanding our carrier access and programs while remaining fully family-owned and Burlington-based.
Affiliate of a Top 100 U.S. independent agency — expanded carrier access, same Burlington team you've always known.
For over 90 years, Mangold Insurance has been woven into the fabric of Burlington and the surrounding region. Our agents coach youth sports, serve on local boards, and show up at the same events our clients do. That's not a marketing strategy — it's just where we live.
When you work with Mangold, you're working with your neighbors. People who have a stake in this community because it's their community too.
See how we give back →We adopted Riverside Park in Burlington — mulching, planting, and maintaining a community space our neighbors use every day.
We serve on the Experience Burlington Chamber board — helping shape the events and business community that makes Burlington worth calling home.
We support Burlington-area 4H programs and FFA chapters — investing in the next generation of farmers, ranchers, and community leaders.
Jim Mangold is a recipient of the Jack Ryan Community Service Award — recognition from the industry for commitment to community, not just business.
4.9 stars across 43 reviews. Here's what Burlington-area clients, commercial accounts, and families say about working with Mangold.
"Stephen has always been responsive to the needs of my clients. He clearly and accurately explains the risks he's analyzing for their unique set of circumstances, and makes recommendations for coverage that fit their needs. I've always seen him display a truly "client first" mentality! The whole team at Mangold Insurance is wonderful to work with!"
— Brad Lois · Google review
"I have been with Mangold for over 10 years. For one year I switched, but was very dissatisfied with the quality of service I received. My agent, Sue, takes care of me, answering all of my questions and regularly checking in to see if I need anything. I highly recommend Mangold Insurance for all of your business needs."
— Kate Bender · Google review
"I have been working with Sue Tuma at Mangold Insurance since we purchased Abraham's On-Site Shredding Service in 2016. Sue was very helpful in getting all the insurance we needed and has been there every time we needed her. Sue is always there to answer my questions, adjust my coverage and provide Certificates of Insurance when needed."
— Larry Bangs · Abraham's On-Site Shredding · Burlington, WI
In 2019 Mangold joined Robertson Ryan — a Top 100 U.S. independent agency based in Milwaukee. The partnership expanded our carrier programs and market access. Mangold remains fully family-owned and locally operated from Burlington. Same team. Better tools.
We write insurance anywhere in the U.S. Tell us what you need and we'll shop 100+ carriers. No pressure, no obligation — we take the time to get it right.
