Claims

​Our goal is to make it as easy as possible for you to file claims and make changes to your insurance coverage.
Choose one of three options that works best for you.

• ​​Call us and we’ll do the work for you!
• Use our mobile app to complete the tasks with your smartphone. (Contact us to receive a download.)
• Contact your carrier using the numbers provided to file claims.

​For Non-Emergency Claims:
​

• Call 262.763.7644 or 800.242.2282 during normal business hours (Mon.- Fri. 8am to 5pm) to report your claim directly to your customer service agent.
  or
• Call your insurance company directly using the 24 hour claim numbers listed below.

For Emergency Claims:

​To report an emergency claim such as a serious loss involving bodily injury, substantial property damage, a serious fire, etc. please see below:

• During normal business hours please call 262.763.7644 or 800.242.2282 (Mon.- Fri. 8am to 5pm).
  or
• After hours call 262.763.7644 and you will be directed to our paging service and a representative will be paged to return your call.
• Call your insurance company direct using the 24 hour claim numbers listed below.​

​Insurance Company 24 hour claim phone numbers:

​Locate the name and phone number below of the insurance company who issued your policy. Have your policy number ready and call the 24 hour claim reporting phone number shown:

Acuity
800-242-7666 press 2
AIG/Chartis
888-760-9195 press 2
Allianz
800-242-7698
Allied Glass
800-282-1446
Amerisafe
800-256-9052
AmTrust
888-887-3062
Argent
877-922-5246
ASI
866-274-5677
Assurant/was Trav Flood
800-654-4895
Auto Owners
888-252-4626
Badger Mutual
414-383-1234
Berkshire Guard
800-639-2567
Berkshire Hathaway
800-356-5750
Captial Ins. of Wisconsin
262-781-8080
Chubb (ACE)
800-252-4670 press 1
Cincinnati
877-242-2544
CNA
877-262-2727
Crum & Foster
800-690-5520
Dairyland
800-325-9559
EMC
888-362-2255
Employers
888-362-2255
First Comp/Markel Specialty
888-500-3344
Foremost
800-527-3907
Frankenmuth Mutual
800-234-4433
Germantown Mutual
800-236-4642
Grand River
517-925-1643
Greatway
800-242-7666
Hagerty
800-747-5348
Hanover
800-628-0250
Hartford
800-243-5860
Hastings
800-422-8277
ICW Group
800-877-1111
IMT Group
800-274-3531
Integrity Mutual Insurance
800-445-3030
Kemper
800-242-8808
For glass only losses call
888-252-2799, option 1
For towing
855-849-3858

​Liberty Mutual
800-225-2467
Met/PakII
800-854-6011
press 1 for glass& towing/ press 2 all other
MiddleOak
800-255-2533
Middlesex Mutual AssuranceCo.
800-344-3454
Nationwide
877-638-4244
Nationwide Ag
800-228-6700
Olympus
866-281-2242
Philadelphia
800-765-9749
Progressive
800-274-4055
Progressive Glass
800-274-4499
Progressive Roadside Assistance
800-287-5078
Pure
888-813-7873
QBE
844-723-2524
Safeco
800-332-3226
Secura
800-318-2316
800-828-7047 (After Hours)
Selective
866-455-9969
Selective Flood
877-348-0552 option 2
Seneca
800-442-5723
Sentry
800-473-6879
SFM
800-937-1181
Sheboygan Falls
800-321-9998
Society
888-576-2438
800-945-7120 (After Hours)
Travelers
800-252-4633 (Personal)
800-238-6225 (Business)
Travelers boat claims
800-772-4482
Travelers Flood
800-356-6670, press 1
West Bend Mutual
877-922-5246
Westfield
800-443-3311
Western National
855-921-3164
Zurich
800-987-3373