Short answer: If a serious accident could cost more than the liability limit on your auto or home policy, you should think about an umbrella. It adds $1 million or more of liability coverage on top of those policies, and it often costs a few hundred dollars a year. People with a home, savings, a teen driver, a pool, a boat or a rental property are the ones who usually need it most.

What is umbrella insurance?

An umbrella policy is extra liability coverage that sits on top of your auto, home, boat and recreation vehicle policies. If you're sued for an accident and the claim is bigger than your regular policy's limit, the umbrella pays the rest, up to its own limit.

It also pays for your legal defense, which can add up fast even when you did nothing wrong.

How does it work in a real claim?

Here's a simple example. Say you cause a car accident and the other driver's injuries lead to a $750,000 judgment against you.

$750,000 judgmentWithout an umbrellaWith a $1 million umbrella
Your auto policy pays$250,000 (your limit)$250,000 (your limit)
Umbrella paysNothing$500,000
You owe out of pocket$500,000$0

That $500,000 can come from your savings, your home equity or even your future paychecks. The umbrella is there so it doesn't.

Why isn't my auto or home policy enough?

Wisconsin only requires $25,000 of liability coverage for one person's injuries, $50,000 for everyone hurt in one accident and $10,000 for property damage on the auto policy. Most people carry more than that, but a bad accident can still go well past $250,000 or $500,000 once medical bills, lost wages and legal costs add up.

An umbrella can also cover some claims your home policy may not, like being sued for libel or slander.

Who should think about an umbrella policy?

You should ask about one if any of these fit you:

What do I need before I can buy one?

Insurance companies want your regular policies to carry higher limits first, so the umbrella only kicks in for the big claims. Most insurers want at least $250,000 of liability on your auto policy and $300,000 on your home policy before they'll sell you a $1 million umbrella.

If your limits are lower today, raising them is part of the cost. Ask your agent to price both together so you see the full picture.

What does an umbrella cost?

Umbrella policies are one of the cheaper ways to protect what you own. The Insurance Information Institute says $1 million of coverage typically costs $200 to $300 a year. Your price depends on things like how many drivers and vehicles you have, your claims history and whether you own boats, recreational vehicles or rental property.

What doesn't an umbrella cover?

Most personal umbrella policies won't pay for:

Read the policy for other exclusions, such as certain watercraft or recreational vehicles.

What should I ask my agent?

  1. Are my auto and home liability limits high enough to add an umbrella?
  2. What would $1 million cost me, and what about $2 million?
  3. Are my boat, recreational vehicles, cabin and any rental property included?

Mangold Insurance helps families across Wisconsin, Illinois and Iowa set up umbrella coverage that fits with their home and auto policies. We'll check your limits and shop the umbrella for you.

Frequently asked questions

In most cases, yes. An umbrella usually covers the people in your household who are covered on your auto policy, including a teen driver. Make sure every driver is listed on your auto policy.
It can, as long as the boat, recreational vehicles or second home has its own liability coverage at the limits the umbrella requires. Tell your agent about every boat and property so none are left out. If you have a dock, see what your lake home policy covers.
Yes. Your renters policy's liability coverage can count as the base for an umbrella, along with your auto policy.
No. A lawsuit can go after your home equity, savings and future income, not just a big bank account. If one bad day could cost more than your policy limits, an umbrella is worth pricing.

Sources

This article is general information, not a coverage determination. What an umbrella covers depends on the policy you buy and the insurance company's underwriting.

Want to know if you need an umbrella, and what it would cost? We'll check your limits and shop it for you. Request a quote →

← All resources Talk to an agent →
Related articles