Geneva Lake has drawn discerning property owners since wealthy Chicagoans built their estates here after the Great Chicago Fire of 1871. High-value lakefront homes, resort businesses, and a tourism economy that demands specific coverage expertise. Mangold Insurance delivers that — with 100+ carriers and genuine SE Wisconsin roots.
We take the time to thoroughly evaluate your needs
No obligation. 100+ carriers. We work for you.
Lake Geneva is one of Wisconsin's premier resort communities — where lakefront homes sell for $1M–$5M+, seasonal visitors outnumber year-round residents, and the hospitality economy creates specific commercial coverage needs. Standard homeowners policies are routinely inadequate for the property values and specific risks of the Geneva Lake market.
We write lakefront and high-value property coverage that actually reflects what you own — proper dwelling limits, dock and boathouse coverage, watercraft programs, and vacation rental coverage for Airbnb and VRBO owners along Geneva Lake. As an independent agency with 100+ carriers, we find programs built specifically for high-value lake properties.
"I have been working with Sue Tuma at Mangold Insurance since we purchased our business. Sue is always there to answer my questions, adjust my coverage, and provide Certificates of Insurance when needed. Very happy with the service."
— Larry Bangs · Google review
"The company I work for has their commercial insurance with Mangold, and they are AWESOME to work with. They are always looking out for our best interest and respond so quickly to all our requests and needs."
— Kristen Bangert · Facebook review
Home, farm, business, and everything in between — one independent agency with 100+ carriers for southeastern Wisconsin.
Homeowners, auto, renters, watercraft, and umbrella — we shop 100+ carriers for the right combination for southeastern Wisconsin families.
Jefferson and Walworth county farming deserves real farm policies — not homeowners add-ons. Structures, equipment, livestock, and farm liability.
General liability, workers' comp, commercial auto, and commercial property for SE Wisconsin businesses — including cross-border IL coverage.
Mangold covers communities across Walworth, Racine, Jefferson, Kenosha, Waukesha, and Rock counties.
No pressure, no obligation. We take the time to thoroughly evaluate your needs — then shop 100+ carriers for the right fit.